Tuesday, January 12, 2021

Local "Planning" Follies - part 7 Some Conclusions

Some Conclusions

(c) by Mark Dempsey 

Part of a series. See Local "Planning" Follies Part 1 - The state of play in land use planning for links to all posts.

Peaking oil production—or political turmoil that makes supplies unreliable— climate change, growing (and increasingly alienated) populations, water and power shortages, and a host of other intrusions of ecology into our economy are signs that we are reaching the limits of the physical environment’s ability to support our civilization. We must change how we live on or own or have change “forced on us with chaos and suffering by the inexorable laws of nature.” 

The biggest attraction of New Urbanist civic design is that it develops cities with lower environmental impacts than sprawl, and offers many advantages unavailable to sprawl residents. Since it promotes walking, and less pollution, it’s healthier too.

But what can we do now that will be effective to promote this return to the traditional way of building cities? With the understanding that change will not occur overnight, here are a few suggestions:

  • Educate people about the 1970-71 peak in U.S. domestic oil production, and about how palliative fracking has been (wells play out faster). Without this education, complacent people are not motivated to support alternative civic design, or transportation infrastructure.
  • Demand more intelligent management of the public realm from local governments—if only so our current, unintended subsidies don’t bankrupt our cities. Local governments hear you, as a constituent, much more than state or national officials do.

It's not possible to persuade people to abandon amenities like private yards if they can't trust the city or county to make public parks available. The required public policy change—actually informing the public so more intelligent decisions can be made—is what this writing promotes.

If we do not start doing these things, the deterioration of our communities will continue unabated. We will also lose whatever global advantage we might have had, and start down the slippery slope of the decline of empire.

Some Myths Debunked

Myth 1: The market will make a pleasant, moral, safe, efficient society, rather than vice-versa. The Truth: We cannot trust “the market” or any other form of automatic pilot to come up with intelligent public policy. Markets themselves require regulation to referee, provide safe places for them to occur, and to account for externalities.

Myth 2: The experts know best. The Truth: “Experts” got us sprawl. The amateurs built the really great cities like London and Paris.

Myth 3: We build villages because it takes a village to raise a child. The Truth: Currently, we build things that may be deceptively labelled “village,” but they are typically single-use, pedestrian-unfriendly sprawl. Sprawl does its best to maximize privacy at the expense of the neighborly concern, or the public spaces where it can be exercised.

Myth 4: Politeness and excuses from politicians are enough. No one is more polite than politicians, in my experience. And no one is better at making you feel like you’re “special.” The Truth: Not enough. Give me a rude leader who gets the right things done. We desperately need effective, imaginative public policy, not better excuses.

Myth 5: We are not interconnected, and can do without public policy “meddling.” The Truth: We’re so interconnected, the average person can’t even make a writing instrument (pencil, pen). We don’t grow our own food, treat our own water, or sewage; we don’t do our own mosquito abatement; we don’t produce our own vaccines, or electricity, or clothing. In short, we are very interdependent. If we do not manage that interdependence successfully, we will suffer as a civilization and individually.

Signs, Hopeful and Otherwise

In 1860, the capital city of Washington, with a population of 60,000, had unlighted streets, open sewers, and pigs roaming about its principal avenues. This condition was worse than the worst of our current cities. There is hope.—Andres Duany

Trends for the future are not all bleak. There are hopeful signs that local leaders are slowly waking up to the potential for better public policy. SACOG’s regional Blueprint process—a series of hearings and presentations to educate the public about land use—is one of the best new items on the horizon.

Why? The recent Blueprint process is one of the first local planning processes to actually educate the public about the costs and benefits of various alternatives. It is not nearly as educational as I would like, but it deserves a lot of credit for introducing something other than the cloud-cuckoo land of the public’s wishful thinking. In a refreshing change, the recent General Plan Update conducted by the County of Sacramento was similarly concerned with consequences—although it still discussed none of the financial implications of the alternatives discussed. 

Some of the public still wanted only rural development, and one said he was opposed to the County telling anyone how they could develop their land, apparently detecting the Stalinist flavor of planning as currently practiced.

Nevertheless, the tide appears to be turning. A recent speech from the Blueprint project’s chief—past directory of SACOG—Mike McKeever suggests re-prioritizing land use based on how it impacts our petroleum use. So some policy makers “get it.”

On the minus side, the rest of this writing documents many of the foibles of government as it tries to shovel public money into private pockets—often to the detriment of the common good. Pedestrian-friendly, mixed-use neighborhoods, particularly ones built more compactly, relies on active government participation—and not just in the development’s initial phases, either. Not only do residences with smaller yards demand parks, but they demand security, and the will to maintain the parks and safety they require.

The big question is whether we can trust local governments to be anything more than their misguided past. Can they actually practice enlightened, imaginative design, or are they destined to be mired in endless hearings designed to obscure rather than enlighten?

It’s become fashionable lately to deride government as something that can only meddle, and be unhelpful. This fashionable cynicism has blossomed into an industry where, as New York Times editorialist, Thomas Frank says “The true scoffer... can see that government is not merely susceptible to corruption; government is corruption, a vile profaning of the market-most-holy in which some groups contrive to swipe the property of other groups via taxation and regulation.”

To me, suggesting that a dislike for corruption means a dislike for government is throwing the baby out with the bath water. It’s still possible to have good governance that really does perform public service. Examples of shared responsibility for shared goods are too common to ignore (like Curitiba—The Third World Gets It in a previous post).

Conservative economist Milton Friedman observes that there are four ways to spend money.

  • You can spend your money on yourself, which means you’ll get just what you want at a pretty good price.
  • You can spend your money on others, which means they’ll get what you like, not necessarily what they like, and you won’t spend too much.
  • You can spend someone else’s money on yourself. People get what they want, and spare no expense, so not at a bargain price.
  • And you can spend other people’s money on other people, in which case, who cares what they get or whether it’s a good deal?

This last option is too often the mode of government spending. The remedy, obviously, is to remember that we’re spending our money on ourselves.

The temptation to dismiss all government efforts as futile remains strong. Given the performance of local governments documented here, or simply an encounter with government’s attempt to settle disputes in the courts, most people will say there could be nothing worse. The real question is whether we can set aside our cynicism, and adopt a clear vision of what public service really means.
Unfortunately, there is something worse: the un-governed alternative.

Epilogue: The Pressure Continues

Because of the subsidies and incentives offered sprawl builders, and because Sacramento’s growth continues, the pressure to develop even more outlying land is unrelenting. Sprawl is still very profitable, even if it is in floodplain behind weak levees. 

Therefore, I wrote the Supervisors recently to protest their move to change the Urban Service Boundary (the limit for sewer and water), and their acts to subsidize growth in floodplain. 

Then Supervisor Roger Dickinson replied. He wrote that the Supervisors were simply consulting with the City of Sacramento about how to “implement the Joint Vision for Natomas.” He added that I needn’t worry about the levees, he expected them to provide 200-year flood protection before any development occurred in this expansion to North Natomas development.

Here is my reply (slightly edited to fit in this context):

Dear Supervisor Dickinson,

Your reply to my letter protesting the expansion of the Urban Services Boundary reminds me of a previous encounter when a group of concerned parents at Rio Linda's West Side School were gathered to meet with you. We were worried that speeding cars would endanger the kids crossing West Second as they came to school (the danger had been bad for some time, but increased development was making it much worse).

West second is an old rural road that had been widened as part of the County's efforts to implement its street design standards when adjacent, new subdivisions were built. For internal streets in new subdivisions, these widths are such invitations to speeding that the County's design standards requires the streets to bend every 1,000 lineal feet (hence the “spaghetti streets” of suburbia). Widening an old rural road like West Second, which is straight as an arrow, is doubly bad: it invites faster auto speeds without any obstacle like the bends of spaghetti streets, and provides increased exposure to danger for crossing students because they spend more time crossing a wider street.

When the assembled parents first asked you to do something about West Second, you replied that there must be a thousand project requests like this throughout the County, and they typically took six years to get approved. 

I remember thinking then: “What would Roger say to a pharmacist who told him his child's medicine would be ready in six years, with one chance in a thousand that he'd get it even then?...I mean I wonder what he would say after he vaulted over the counter to strangle the pharmacist threatening his child's health?...”

In a triumph of retail politics—and possibly because I suggested it—you managed to get the County to narrow the road in front of West Side School.

But retail, transaction-by-transaction public policy is not the complaint I had about the County then, nor is it why I wrote to protest changes to the Urban Service Boundary.

My beef is that the County's public policy is, let's just say, less-than-optimum; it manages transactions without vision. 

The County still mandates, and developers still build, wider roads exactly like those on West Second. According to planning staff, the County has no plans to change its murderous street design standards even when it holds hearings for the General Plan update. [Update: The State of California now requires "Complete Streets" of all new development. These streets accommodate pedestrians, transit, cyclists as well as autos... So good news!]

That's bad public policy. The County continues to build more such street problems with each new development, and I'm guessing that the six-year chance-in-a-thousand hasn't improved much either. This ignores the law of holes: To get out of the hole, first stop digging.

As for the subject of my original e-mail: No matter how you slice it, rezoning more North Natomas land would hand the land speculators another gigantic payday. You may have some tiny triumph in the negotiations, but it's very, very bad public policy to do this kind of thing. (And what happened to that ordinance about handing special favors to individuals?)

I don't care if it's to “implement the Joint Vision for Natomas”—your words—or to provide a home for the Easter Bunny. It's bad public policy to, in effect, subsidize outlying development that lengthens commutes in floodplain surrounded by weak levees. Excuses, even fine “joint vision” excuses, don't make it any better.

The Dutch, by the way, have 10,000 year flood protection. That's what good public policy looks like.
Another good public policy example: When rezoning, the Germans require developers to sell the land to the County at the current zoning's price, then before they can build, the developers must buy it back when it's rezoned (at the higher, rezoned price). All the profits stay with the County which, by any measurement, is their source anyway. There is no “unearned increment” subsidizing the worst kind of development, and providing huge paydays for land speculators.

An alternative good policy was the Romans'. They financed their famous roads by increasing taxes on adjacent land when public amenities (like the road) made the land more valuable. This would at least diminish the subsidy and pay for the amenity.

We have neither the German nor the Roman strategy. Sacramento County's strategy, if it can be called that, is to shovel as much public money as possible out the door to the oligarchy of land speculators and commercial interests, even if we have a deficit so bad Head Start kids can't get dental care (true!). At the height of the recent building boom, the County budget deficit was “the worst in living memory” said Illa Collin.

Yet Former Supervisor Collin believes taxing rezones “politically impossible,” and former County Supervisor Roberta MacGlashan says she thinks it's “illegal” (this after hearing some truly outrageous, self-contradictory public policy suggestions in a public meeting, and protesting none of them).

The negotiated proposal to subsidize the basketball arena is similarly awful, by the way. Any deal that would be bettered by gifting the arena to the team's owners is at least awful, and you know it. And yes, I've read that the profits from developing the old arena's land would mitigate this disaster, but I'm not even buying that. Why isn't the County (and the public) profiting from the rest of North Natomas where we effectively handed a many-thousands percent profit to the land speculators? How is this any different than the “hand-the-money-to-the-oligarchs” strategy?

By your reply, all I can deduce is that the County is consistent. This is not reassuring in the slightest. It's certainly not the policy consistency I've been looking for.

Someone once told me that you either get the desired result or the excuses. Therefore, I'd like to nominate Sacramento County as the World's champion maker of excuses. Terrific at retail politics, but when it comes to real public policy: We've got the finest excuses money can buy.
Shameful, really.

Local "Planning" Follies part 6 “Friends”—The Missing Community

“Friends”—The Missing Community

(c) by Mark Dempsey 

Part of a series. See Local "Planning" Follies Part 1 - The state of play in land use planning for links to all posts.

Sprawl is notorious for isolating people. That is one of the hallmarks of its design: maximum privacy and precious little space for social interaction. Suburbs are famously devoid of any culture except television. 

The British are different. Compared to its U.S. counterpart—aside from a few brilliant productions—British TV is awful. It has only four channels, and “shows” like two presenters asking callers to identify a mystery card, naming another TV presenter. Banter can only carry so much. 

Apparently the Brits don’t have the motivation, or population, to need a gazillion cable channels for entertainment (although I'm sure they have cable by now). They can manage with public broadcast of only four channels and a few brilliant shows because they have something the U.S. does not have: pubs. 

Pubs (short for “public houses”) are not exactly bars, although they serve alcohol. They also serve food. They also have public gatherings for football (soccer) matches and other entertainments. 

Visiting England on business, I once bought a British cab driver lunch. We were sitting in the pub and a fellow with a blue-and-brown afro wig rushed past us to yell the score in a game to his fellow fans. “He’s British,” counselled my cabbie, with a knowing smile, “we don’t pay him.”

So the Brits find each other entertaining. The pub we ate in advertised “?uiz Nite!” every Wednesday. The English don’t watch others answer Alex Trebec’s questions on Jeopardy, they play “?uiz” themselves—far more satisfying entertainment, if you ask me.

As mentioned before, pubs are typically within a walk of homes, and the availability of their community entertainment—and the walk—may be at the root of the difference between American and British health. A recent study discovered that the British diet was not particularly healthier, and they weren’t even less obese than Americans, but British patients were significantly healthier. 

Could the U.S. health effect something resulting from the missing community discussed in works like Robert Putnam’s Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community?

Says Putnam: “Television, two-career families, suburban sprawl, generational changes in values—these and other changes in American society have meant that fewer and fewer of us find that the League of Women Voters, or the United Way, or the Shriners, or the monthly bridge club, or even a Sunday picnic with friends fits the way we have come to live. Our growing social-capital deficit threatens educational performance, safe neighborhoods, equitable tax collection, democratic responsiveness, everyday honesty, and even our health and happiness.” 

Putnam, is a Harvard professor of sociology who charts the past two generations’ deterioration of the organized ways people engage in civic life in the U.S. One example he cites: in 1960, 62.8% of Americans of voting age participated in the presidential election, whereas by 1996, the percentage had slipped to 48.9%. (See this more recent blog post about the current state of voting in the U.S.)

Most Americans still claim a serious “religious commitment,” but church attendance is down roughly 25%-50% from the 1950s, and the number of Americans who attended public meetings of any kind dropped 40% between 1973 and 1994. Even the once stable norm of community life has shifted: one in five Americans moves once a year, while two in five expect to move in five years. This has created a U.S. population that is increasingly isolated and less sympathetic toward fellow citizens, one that is often angrier and less willing to unite in communities or as a nation.


Monday, January 11, 2021

Local "Planning" Follies, part 5... Curitiba—The Third World Gets It

Curitiba—The Third World Gets It

(c) by Mark Dempsey

Part of a series. See Local "Planning" Follies Part 1 - The state of play in land use planning for links to all posts.

In 2006, the Sacramento’s Great Valley Conference hosted a talk by one of the world’s foremost city planners, the former mayor of Curitiba Brazil, Jaime Lerner. Lerner’s tenure is an inspiration because, even with limited, third world resources, his administration produced world-beating improvements in Curitiba’s quality of life. Lerner himself says that political will and core responsibility, not scale or finances, are what have led to Curitiba’s extraordinary accomplishments.

Lerner’s program was not, however, a dictatorship. To empower the citizens, projects were chosen by referenda in order to assure that they met real needs. Voters in a neighborhood knew the relative costs, and then chose between projects.

The crown jewel of Curitiba’s imaginative public policy is its transit system. As a city whose population now approaches 1.8 million, Curitiba became big enough for the Brazilian government to fund the beginnings of a subway. Mayor Lerner’s team discovered, however, that a subway, or heavy rail scheme would be ten times more expensive than light rail, and that light rail would be ten times more expensive than buses, even one with dedicated busways (“bus rapid transit,” or BRT).

The problem is that, even though a BRT system is much cheaper to build, its operating expenses exceed rail because a bus driver can only carry 40 – 80 passengers. So bus systems need more drivers, and the drivers’ salaries make bus more expensive to operate than single-driver, multi-car trains.

At this point, most public officials would have thrown up their hands, and settled for light rail, but Lerner’s administration got Volvo to manufacture three-section accordion buses that can carry 300 passengers. Lerner also promoted compact development along BRT corridors, so the transit stops are within a walk of enough customers to be viable.

The result is Curitiba’s “Speedybus” system. It enjoys increasing ridership even though per-capita car ownership is rising, something that not even European transit systems can boast. Speedybus BRT provides a bus every thirty seconds, and makes a profit. To give you an idea of the scale of this enterprise, Curitiba's mass transit volumes were 25,000 a day in 1974 and 2,000,000 passengers a day in 2000.

Speedybus BRT even sidesteps the usual debate about whether public services should be publicly or privately run. The city owns the routes, stops and fares, and private enterprise owns the buses. Naturally city planning supports transit.


Curitiba city planning has tall buildings flank the busways so many riders can walk to the stops.

Clean Slums and Bays

Another example of Curitiba’s innovative public policies: Curitiba is poor enough to have slums, but they are clean. This is not because Lerner magically widened slum streets so garbage trucks could visit them, but because he instituted a program to exchange a transit pass or bag of groceries for a bag of garbage. The slums are now self-cleaning.

In his Sacramento lecture, Lerner told of another cleanup in Curitiba’s nearby bays. Lerner agreed to pay the fishermen who worked these bays for the garbage they caught in their nets when fishing. Fishermen can now work year-round, even if the fish are not in season, and get paid. The result of their labor: a cleaner bay with more fish, and millions in savings for Curitiba.

Curitiba's education system promotes its sustainable legacy, civic heritage and history, politically empowering the next generation in the process. Lerner says that the kids teach the parents.
The education is fun, too, full of skits, and costumes. Lerner’s slideshow had a picture of the “leaf” family (people in tree suits) delivering an ecology lesson to young Curitibans. The city even has a free university for the environment. “Why not train everyone about the environment, even the janitors?” says Lerner.

Lerner’s final words: “It is possible. You can do it. Si, es possible”

Local "Planning" Follies, part 4 - WalMart

 (c) by Mark Dempsey

Part of a series. See Local "Planning" Follies Part 1 - The state of play in land use planning for links to all posts.

WalMart

The two sections that follow—Part I: Heads, You Lose; Tails, the WalMart Wins and Part II: Even WalMart Fans Don’t Like County Policies—discuss public reactions to a single land-use proposal to build a WalMart store in at the intersection of two boulevards near my home: Greenback and Hazel.
Our County Supervisor claims she was completely surprised by the application, despite the presence of a deteriorated commercial building on the site for the last several years.

Part I: Heads, You Lose; Tails, the WalMart Wins

Sacramento County Supervisor MacGlashan responded to public disenchantment with a proposed WalMart (at Greenback and Hazel) with a startling revelation: the County could do nothing to stop WalMart. Her explanation: this property already has big-box retail on it (a furniture store in a renovated older supermarket), and is zoned for commerce, so the County's hands are tied. 

Apparently, whenever a land speculator or developer wants a rezone or plan change the Supervisors are more than willing to be flexible, but if the public even wants a review of an important project, all of a sudden our zoning laws have arrived on stone tablets engraved by lightening. What makes this transformation occur?

Ms. MacGlashan’s e-mailed response to this objection: “I consider the lack of opportunity for public input and additional environmental information (such as a traffic study) on a project of this magnitude a serious flaw in the Zoning Code. I am willing to and plan to advocate for changes in the code to address these issues. However, the County cannot change the rules in the middle of the game, so to speak, and the current property owner has the right to develop under the provisions of the code currently in effect.”

The “can't change the rules in the middle of the game” rule is a new one. When did the Supervisors enact this? Don’t the County’s actions potentially interrupt some plan somewhere, regardless of when the action occurs? And can Supervisors pass a building moratorium? At the drop of a hat! Can we enact legal obstacles to WalMart—apparently folks in Contra Costa County believe so, because they have an ordinance that prohibits WalMart. Turlock and Hercules, both within a few miles of Sacramento have successfully opposed WalMart in their towns, too.

Can we even call a “time-out” in the development “game” until new policies are in place, even if they mean improved land use? 

No. That contradicts the “can't change the rules in the middle of the game” rule, one very similar to Catch-22. So it's heads, ordinary citizens lose; tails, the commercial interests or developers win.
This “can't change the rules” handicap is apparently one of the least of the County's disabilities when it comes to managing growth. Call me a dreamer, but I can imagine a day when government represents people, not commercial interests, or land speculators. I can even imagine a government more interested in effective governance than formulating ever-better excuses. You may say I'm a dreamer...but I'm not the only one.

Part II: Even WalMart Fans Don’t Like County Policies

After I wrote to oppose it, a woman we’ll call “Carol” wrote me e-mail saying “Why do you not like WalMart? I am very excited it is coming to Orangevale. It will save me from going to Folsom [the location of the next-nearest WalMart].” 

At the risk of sounding like a boring, eat-your-vegetables parent, I told her my opposition has almost nothing to do with WalMart itself, or Carol’s shopping convenience. You can read about WalMart as exploitive, a bad deal, and so on at websites like www.wakeupwalmart.com, but that's not my primary objection.

Primarily, I object to the County showering benefits on commercial and development interests while it has precious little but excuses to offer its ordinary citizens. The County can change existing zoning whenever land speculators propose some development, and has done so frequently. 

Consider these recent examples of zoning changes just in the last few years: 20 acres at the nearby corner of Pecan and Greenback, Safeway’s proposed shopping center at nearby Madison and Hazel, or 6,000 acres of agricultural land proposed for development at Sunrise/Douglas. None of these properties were developed according to existing planning. 

The 20 acres at Pecan and Greenback could have adopted designs proposed by the Regional Blueprint, the County General Plan, the Community Plan, or even a 35-page “Special Planning Area” (SPA) document on file at the County recorder’s office. The number of hours spent formulating and holding hearings about the SPA alone is daunting even to contemplate. The sprawl built there follows none of these plans. And that is business as usual.

So zoning is, as currently practiced, at least flexible. But let citizens complain about what's permitted by existing zoning (like the proposed WalMart), and suddenly these zoning regulations are cast in stone, and there's simply nothing to be done. 

Just in terms of negotiating with applicants, this is terrible public policy. Because it’s such a pushover, the County has almost no leverage to ask commercial applicants to mitigate impacts like traffic, noise or litter. Because of this, the County certainly has much more difficulty requesting a redesign so a project would have lower impacts.

If the rezone give-aways described in Why Bother Planning? in a previous post and Subsidizing Sprawl – North Natomas and the Environmentalists in another weren't bad enough, the standard big-box store designs the County regularly approves ensure that virtually all shopping continues to be in an automobile—despite the “Transit-Oriented Development” design guidelines in its 1993 General Plan. 

Carol might reply: But there are sidewalks in front of WalMart. If the neighbors want to walk or ride their bicycles there, they could. My answer: Those sidewalks end within a block of the proposed WalMart’s property, and current street design makes walking or cycling a hassle, if not downright dangerous. Not even the present General Plan update hearings include some provision for redesigning streets to be pedestrian-friendly with, for example, setback, wider sidewalks, or less glaring lights. (Although since I wrote this, the state mandated "Complete Streets"...so good news there!)

Carol might also say: But most people have cars, and prefer using them, so why bother making streets pedestrian-friendly? The answer: Because we want less traffic congestion now (it’s one of the top public policy concerns in most polls), and want to start building infrastructure alternatives to automobiles for the future. The current high price of petroleum is just the latest in a long series of price rises that began after the 1971 peak of U.S. domestic oil production (price of a barrel of oil then: $1.75)—a peak to which we will never return even if we produce all the projected Alaska and offshore oil. For more about this, see Thinking Globally: the Petroleum Problem, below

A prudent transportation policy would start building alternatives to single-occupant autos now, rather than scrambling to provide them when (not if) gas reaches $10 a gallon. If we discourage pedestrians and cyclists, project-by-project, even if it makes WalMart and Carol happy, we will continue to ensure the failure of transit, bicycling, or any alternative to autos. We will also continue to send our kids overseas in resource wars to ensure that oil imports are reliable.

So while I’d be happy for Carol to have a shorter drive to WalMart, I’m unhappy that she cannot see the dire consequences for the policies that subsidize and encourage the slam-dunk that WalMart’s approval is likely to be.

After I sent her this information, Carol wrote me to agree, not about WalMart, but that the County’s planning policies were something she disliked. Not even WalMart fans like the way the County handles land use.

Road Widenings Are Not the Congestion Solution

In a typical puff piece, the Sacramento Bee wrote to praise the proposed widening of Hazel Avenue as good, popular, and overdue. This is the story we generally tell ourselves about widening such large roads—it’s progress after all—but is that the whole story?

Given the alternatives presented to the public — basically that we can either keep existing roads as they are or widen them in the face of increasing traffic congestion — it's no great surprise that road widenings are popular, if expensive, solutions to that same traffic congestion. But are they the best or even the only solution? 

The biggest problem with such “solutions” is that they do not last. Though it may seem self-evident that a wider road would solve congestion problems by increasing road capacity, even the proponents of widening Hazel admit that their solution is only temporary. They estimate that traffic will return to present congestion levels within a decade.  

Widenings are only a temporary solution because they attract more traffic—traffic engineers call this “induced congestion.” In a decade, traffic will be just as congested as it is now, but in a wider street. And the $60 million, in the case of Hazel's widening, will be gone — spent on asphalt rather than other public goods. Typically, we are ready to impoverish the public realm, short-changing schools, parks, and other public spaces, but gold-plate amenities for autos.

Real, permanent congestion solutions are available, but the public seldom hears about them. Since most Hazel Avenue traffic is local, the most obvious permanent solution would be to design neighborhoods so people would not have to drive to local destinations. 

Why not build neighborhoods that integrate offices, schools and commerce, making them within a short distance of each other, and streets that accommodate alternatives to driving, like walking or biking? Instead of building single use sprawl neighborhoods (all homes, all commerce, or all offices) connected only by auto commutes, why not nip congestion in the bud, by mixing uses, so different destinations would be within a walk or bike ride? 

We could even relieve the congestion on collector streets like Hazel by making local neighborhood streets into a connected network, instead of sprawl spaghetti (the loops and dead ends that lead only to collector streets). Sprawl street design ensures there are no alternative routes besides the collector to any destinations outside the neighborhood. Everyone meets in the traffic jam on the collector street by design. 

Are the alternatives to sprawl untried, more costly or possibly less valuable than sprawl? In a word: No. Traditional development practices virtually identical to the pedestrian-friendly mixed-use proposed here were the rule for centuries before sprawl, the cost of construction is similar and the most valuable real estate in the region (per square foot) is McKinley Park, a beautiful old neighborhood built with the mixed-use, pedestrian friendly design. 

Beginning in 1993, the County's General Plan even included “Transit-Oriented Development” (TOD) guidelines for building real mixed-use, pedestrian-friendly villages, as opposed to sprawl.

Unfortunately, even today, the County prefers to pay to update General Plans it ignores, and $60 million for one street's asphalt, rather than implement these TOD guidelines. 

It may take a village to raise a child, but we've apparently decided to build single-use sprawl instead, and to spend our money widening roads. Will our kids thank us?

Thinking Globally: the Petroleum Problem

Our local governments’ impotence to curb sprawl has more than just local consequences. If we continue to build infrastructure that requires more and more petroleum we will hamstring our own national economy. 

Why? U.S. domestic oil production began an inexorable decline in 1971, one that will continued until fracking came along, but that too will decline, and the decline would continue even if the U.S. produced all the oil projected to be offshore and in Alaska.


From the World Resources Institute (www.wri.org). In fairness, fracking has raised production above the right tail of the above graph, but fracked wells decline much more rapidly than those produced conventionally, and the finances for fracked oil are in crisis. Even the massive oil giant, Exxon, is in trouble. It's recently been removed from the Dow Jones Index for that reason, and bankruptcies among frackers are exploding wherever they operate. ANWR is the Alaska National Wildlife Refuge.

Because we cannot continue to produce more oil domestically, we must increasingly rely on oil imports as our demand increases. Such imports are so essential that since 1971 every recession has coincided with an overseas oil shock. Daniel Yergin’s history of the oil industry describes our increasing dependence on overseas oil imports as the root of the greatest peacetime transfer of wealth in history.

Why is this related to our city design practices? The U.S. consumes twice as much petroleum on transportation—most of it just getting around the city—as it does on all other uses combined (petroleum feedstocks, heating, power generation, etc.). The potential to right this by building less consumption into our infrastructure remains the enduring attraction of New Urbanist city design.

Externalities and petroleum

Part of the problem with the way we use petroleum are the market distortions economists call “Externalities”—costs unaccounted for in the price. The ill health and property damage caused by auto-produced pollution are two such externalities not reflected in the price of gas. The inactivity of driving rather than walking—a side effect of auto-centric civic design—causes disease, and is another such externality. Auto accidents, and some roads autos use are other externalities. 

Because domestic (and worldwide) demand for petroleum increases as economies grow—at least as they do currently—we are also increasingly reliant on imported oil. This is why our military is are overseas guarding oilfields and pipelines in places like Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and Columbia. This military expense is yet another externality unaccounted for in the price at the pump. Oil producers get an income tax write-off called the “depletion allowance.” 

Before the second Iraq war, the World Resources Institute estimated that we subsidize petroleum nearly $300 billion annually. This figure did not include pollution-related costs, but did include roughly $50 billion in overseas military costs. This amount increases if you count the Iraq war expenditures which are running closer to $200 billion annually. 

The World Bank more recently estimated worldwide subsidies for petroleum at $1.2 trillion, and concluded the subsidies are regressive--the wealthy benefit more than poor people.

In a market that charged for these externalities, we would pay more at the pump. Higher costs for a tank of gas would make us re-think when and where we drove, and would encourage public policies that explored alternatives, like transit.

But because externalities amount to effective subsidies for petroleum, and are so pervasive and hidden, what we do is cheapen the tank of gas (so we over-consume), and make alternatives relatively more expensive. This is roughly like giving drivers $5 every time they start their cars, but charging transit passengers for their ride.

Why Compact Sprawl Is an Oxymoron

One of the biggest controversies about returning to pedestrian-friendly development stems from suburbanites’ concern about more compact, denser housing—building more homes on less land. People in the suburbs fear the widely publicized crime, poverty and other inner city woes, not to mention incompetent government management of resources like parks and police that would have much heavier impacts in more compact development. Given the government bumbling described elsewhere in this document, one can hardly blame them, either. 

Most who object to denser development do not know how sprawl design worsens the problems they fear. They are also typically ignorant of bad public policy decisions like red-lining that led to flight from urban areas. 

Red-lining is now illegal, but was common when the government first sponsored 30-year home loans in New Deal programs like FHA. Red-lining meant lenders avoided lending to inner cities, favoring suburban neighborhoods—also favoring whites over blacks. This meant that urban neighborhoods deteriorated, particularly those populated by people of color.

In line with the fear in the suburbs, typical sprawl apartment development design can bring hundreds of strangers into the midst of a suburban neighborhood. The neighbors’ concern about crime is not surprising, especially since sprawl street design discourages the presence of pedestrians who might prevent crime by their presence on the street.

What most objectors don’t know is that denser housing within traditional, pedestrian friendly mixed-use neighborhoods reduces crime because it provides more “eyes on the street,” or more neighbors to stop bad behavior. Jane Jacobs says of her New York City neighborhood: “When Mr. Lacey, the locksmith, bawls out one of my sons for running into the street, and then later reports the transgression to my husband as he passes the locksmith shop, my son gets more than an overt lesson in safety and obedience. He also gets, indirectly, the lesson that Mr. Lacey, with whom we have no other ties other than street propinquity, feels responsible for him to a degree.” One further bit of evidence that this is true: Per-capita crime is higher in low-density suburbanized Sacramento than in high density, pedestrian-friendly New York City.

When Sacramento's General Plan, and more recently the Sacramento Area Council of Governments (SACOG) Blueprint, proposed denser development, some, even some real estate professionals, protested such development would not be marketable. Builders are especially reluctant to face the NIMBY protests about such projects. 

Why encourage the controversial compact development? Commutes, infrastructure and transportation costs—both monetary and environmental—decrease dramatically with compact development, so planners are eager to encourage such projects. Viable mass transit, and neighborhood commerce are impossible without some increase in suburban housing densities.

The Real Objection to Density

Higher density housing offers an inferior lifestyle only when it is without a community as its setting.—Andres Duany
If what you sell is privacy and exclusivity, then every new house is a degradation of the amenity. However, if what you sell is community, then every new house is an enhancement of the asset.—Vince Graham

What suburbanites really object to is dense development designed as sprawl. Typical sprawl apartments or condominiums are a poor imitation of single-family sprawl housing. The design maximizes privacy, but short-changes space for interaction. Such designs offer little or no accommodation for meeting outside the individual unit—there is no “social space.” Most tenants meet neighbors in the parking lot—hardly a place designed for lingering—or when they pound on the common wall to tell their neighbor to turn down the music.

Single family homes, even the standard suburban sprawl models, offer a chance to meet neighbors while doing yard work, walking the dog, or when taking an evening stroll if street design permits—and don’t offer as many opportunities to complain about noise. So when one neighbor asks another to lower the volume, the neighbors typically know each other first as something other than a nuisance, and the whole social fabric of the neighborhood benefits by this mutual accommodation.

Condominiums built according to sprawl designs are also a poor investment in comparison with single-family homes. Their uniformity explains some of this. Because owners who travel or otherwise need lower maintenance housing are among the primary purchasers of condominiums, condo owners often move more frequently than homeowners in single-family suburbs. Since the units are identical, the lowest priced, most desperate seller sets the market price. Even in single-family home sprawl, identical models are distinguished by differing trim and landscaping. Not so condominiums.

Condo prices also stay low because of homeowners' association's dues changes and wrangling. As might be expected, neighbors who have no place for neutral socializing have contentious association meetings that decide neighborhood issues.

The condo dues changes were especially troubling because, initially, the California Department of Real Estate did not sufficiently audit budgets, and dues proposals, in condominium applications. This gave California condominiums a bad reputation when they first were built.

Condominium developers had every incentive to underestimate expenses collected by the association because buyers qualify for loans based on their expenses, including condo dues. The lower the expenses, the more buyers qualify, and the easier it is to sell units. 

Because dues underestimated real expenses, earlier condo owners had to stomach large dues increases when, for example, the roof needed replacing. These increases were anathema to fixed-income retirees who would otherwise be enthusiastic condominium unit buyers. 

Fortunately, pedestrian-oriented development offers the best solution to the most intractable of the problems of high density housing. By design, such pedestrian-friendly neighborhoods offer places to socialize between units. People can meet in a park, or walkway, or front porch. This increases the neutral socializing, and lowers the contentiousness that makes denser development so unpopular with suburbanites. 

Traditional neighborhoods also offer ways to avoid the shock of integrating hundreds of new apartments into a neighborhood—something sprawl apartment design typically demands. Building large homes with eight-unit apartments means the lower-cost apartment units bring social diversity to a neighborhood without the difficulty of integrating hundreds of new strangers.

Building a variety, of units with different plans and facades could be a requirement for any high- density building code. This would keep values up, and eliminate the value-lowering competition for identical units. 

And finally, California’s Department of Real Estate has been more carefully scrutinizing condominium budgets lately. This ended some of the abusively low dues estimates—and the later catastrophic dues hikes.

Educating the public about the possibilities of high density housing is one avenue we can pursue with our planning policies. The alternative is to continue building (and subsidizing) suburban sprawl as we do now.


The best of stand-up

 Here's a very funny, very courageous stand-up comedy set from Janine Harouni: